Tracey Emin at the Hay festival: Photograph: David Levenson.
When British artist Tracey Emin spoke at the Hay Literary Festival in Wales, she talked about happiness, among other issues of her career. According to The Guardian, Emin, 54, argued that she was growing as an artist, compared to the career of her contemporaries. Her contemporaries are members of a well known movement Young British Artists (YBAs).
“I know artists who make the same fucking work day in, day out,” she said. “They make it, they sell it, they make it, they sell it, they make another version, they sell it. They get a bigger house, they sell it. They get another house, they make some more work, they make more of the same work – that is what their fucking life is ... that is not being an artist. Being an artist is about making art, not about making money.”
Emin, who is the most vocal member of the famed YBA of the 1990s, is controversial forquite a number of reasons. Among such are her conceptual work and choice of private life.
Whatever anyone, including Emin says about critical and commercial appreciation of art, is not exactly new: the two have always been viewed as either parallel or together in the art world depending on where your art ideology lies.
But the context in which Emin expressed her view has been taken with mixed reactions on social media. For example, Nigerian independent curator, Bisi Silva who posted The Guardian link of the publication on her facebook drew identical line between Emin's statement and the behavourial pattern of artists in the West African country as regards making money and not art. "Hehehe same in Nja o!!!", Silva wrote on her facebook. 'Nja' or 'Naija' is a funkified word for Nigeria.
Expectedly, the Facebook post by Silva generated comments that ended up dividing contributors along the lines of critical and commercial appreciation of art.
But Emin wasn't speaking within the context of that well known two sides to art appreciation. She was clearly being political within the frame of her local rivalry with some members of the YBAs movement. "It tends to happen much more with male artists," she told her audience. And just in case you still can't get Emin's political tones and possible angst against someone, she clarified: "I’m not talking about Picasso."
That clarification indicated her grouse was confined within a space and of ideological differences among her contemporaries. In fact, she was probably using the opportunity of the Wales event to throw stones at a particular individual artist like Damien Hirst.
The perceived cold war among few of the YBAs, seemed to have been widened with Emin's statement. And clearly it would not be understood in the context of commercial versus critical appreciation at a broader scale.
It was however worrisome that the debate on Silva 's Facebook degenerated to the point of calling people names. For example, those who disagreed with the argument of "making art and not money" were called the "olodos". In English translation 'olodos' is a Yoruba word for dullards. At that point of the debate, I stopped tracking it.
Nothing could be more complex and arrogant as trying to whip other professional colleagues into a particular line of thought in 21 Century debate over an art-related subject.
Every art professional has the right of what to do with their art. And to behave like one Headmaster in spreading your line of thought, please go and set up some kind of school for dummies who won't have their right to think, independent of the headmaster's dictates.
As much as critical and commercial appreciation of art should always go together, it is the right of any artist to strictly stick to one and dump the other or take the two along. In Nigeria, where there is no equivalent of Arts Council England for artists to get grant, it makes little or no sense to blackmail professionals who lean on the commercial side of the divides.